Review of: The Confederate Kit
Super nice for re-enactors. Beautifully etched. Gifted to relative who absolutely loved it.
Reviewed by: Jim, December 24, 2022
Review of: 1840 Ames NCO Sword
I was undecided between this sword and another but when I saw that Windlass was now offering the M1840 NCO sword with a leather sheath that did it. I do not like steel scabbards. It appears that I made a good decision as it handles well being fast and nimble. My biggest issue is in the manner in which Windlass chose to add the nomenclature to the ricasso. I had fully expected it to be stamped but instead it is printed on. Nicely done but printed, I can feel the raised lettering and no doubt in time will wear off, if I don’t accidently use something that will dissolve it first. For a complete review see my review on SBG https://sbg-sword-forum.forums.net/thread/56791/windlass-new-m1840-sword-5000836?page=1
Reviewed by: Paul, March 14, 2019
Review of: 1840 Ames NCO Sword
I was debating whether to buy the #500350 M1840 NCO Sword or one from another company. When I saw that Windlass had put new clothes on their old #500350, namely a leather sheath, and called it #500836 and briefly offered it at a 15% discount I jumped at it. The leather sheath was the selling point. Well, that and the statistics, principally the weight and balance point also helped. The sword is nimble, fast, and easily controlled. The diameter of the grip is a trifle small for my size 8 hand but easily manageable. A glove gives me a better fit. It comes without a washer but I made one from an old leather slingshot pouch without difficulty. The blade is a thrusting blade but after putting a convex razor sharp edge on it, it cuts the traditional soft targets well. The nomenclature on the ricasso was disappointing as it is printed on the surface where it is subject to wearing off or possibly affected by certain solvents. I was expecting it to be stamped into the metal. The grip arrived with a visible parting seam and a bit of flash. I took care of all with a couple of needle files. It’s a 5 starrer in my book.
Reviewed by: Paul, March 02, 2019
Review of: Model 1850 Foot Officer's Sword
I picked this sword up a while back for use in reenactments. It balances just like an original and the blade etching is high quality! The scabbard bluing is very durable and survived a summer of heavy use and abuse in the field. I would recommend this piece to anyone looking for a good quality sword that will survive use and abuse in the field.
Reviewed by: Derek, February 09, 2019
Review of: 1840 Ames NCO Sword
I couldn't be more pleased with this high quality reproduction of a classic sword. It's exactly what I needed for living history/reenacting. I am currently active duty military and have since purchased several more and had them engraved for senior NCO retirement gifts.
if you're looking for a great blade at a great value, look no further.
Reviewed by: Derek, February 09, 2019
Review of: 1859 Sharps Civil War Military Rifle
Beautiful rifle! Well made and perfect vintage look. The working mechanisms are perfect. Fast delivery.
Reviewed by: Gary, January 25, 2019
Review of: 1859 Sharps Civil War Carbine
First I hate that price drop after my purchase however I am guessing it's to offset the dagger. That being said
The replica yesterday it looks like my reenactment sharps. The only thing it would make it better would be if they made one that looks antique.
This will look good in my display case
Reviewed by: arthur, November 22, 2018
Review of: Old West Repeating Rifle
very nice would be better if it could be used as a real rifle
Reviewed by: Alexander, December 24, 2017